Greenbang logo

New ‘World Energy Outlook’: Realistic or fudged?

By Greenbang on Tuesday, 10th November 2009

running-on-emptyThe International Energy Agency (IEA) usually garners a lot of attention when it releases its annual “World Energy Outlook,” but today’s publication follows some much less-welcome attention: news that a whistleblower says the agency has regularly fudged figures to make global oil reserves look better … and fuel production declines look less alarming.

The insider’s comments, reported by The Guardian, suggest the IEA has spun its numbers to minimise fears that the globe has already passed peak oil. The official also claimed the US has encouraged the data manipulation.

The 2009 “World Energy Outlook” itself offers several reasons for raised eyebrows. For one, it sets an atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration goal of 450 parts per million as a target for preventing dangerous climate change; leading climate scientist James Hansen and others say the goal must be no more than 350 parts per million. (Levels currently stand at about 387 parts per million.)

Two, the IEA’s projected oil production outlook for 2030 shows roughly two-thirds of crude oil then coming from “fields yet to be developed or found.”

As one commenter on the peak oil website The Oil Drum noted, “That means about 5 – 6 new Saudi Arabias coming on stream … Those numbers seem highly optimistic to me, or more to the point, downright improbable.”

Upon releasing the new “World Energy Outlook,” the IEA noted, “The time has come to make the hard choices needed to combat climate change and enhance global energy security.”

“World leaders gathering in Copenhagen next month for the UN Climate summit have a historic opportunity to avert the worst effects of climate change,” said Nobuo Tanaka, the IEA’s executive director. “The World Energy Outlook 2009 seeks to add momentum to their negotiations at this crucial stage by detailing the practical steps needed for a sustainable energy future as part of a global climate deal.”

Tanaka added: “WEO-2009 provides both a caution and grounds for optimism. Caution, because a continuation of current trends in energy use puts the world on track for a rise in temperature of up to 6°C and poses serious threats to global energy security. Optimism, because there are cost-effective solutions to avoid severe climate change while also enhancing energy security — and these are within reach as the new Outlook shows.”

Comforting words, if the IEA is in fact not being artificially over-optimistic. If it is … ? Tell us what you think the likely scenario might be in the comments section below.

Tags:

READERS COMMENTS - Have your say...




Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Additional comments powered by BackType

RELATED NEWS

LATEST HEADLINES

One peak we should bring on faster: Peak plastics thumbnail

One peak we should bring on faster: Peak plastics

While most of the peaks we see looming today — peak oil, peak
Jurdy: To the dump, to the dump, to the dump, dump, dump thumbnail

Jurdy: To the dump, to the dump, to the dump, dump, dump

Jurdy finds another tough job to fill …
Finally: A plan to make clean energy a business opportunity thumbnail

Finally: A plan to make clean energy a business opportunity

Ensuring sustainable energy and resources in the future is all about how you
Perfect technology is impossible, but keep trying anyway thumbnail

Perfect technology is impossible, but keep trying anyway

“I guess I could be pretty pissed off about
Plan for a solar future means knowing when the sun won’t shine thumbnail

Plan for a solar future means knowing when the sun won’t shine

While energy experts elsewhere are looking for answers to
Wild warming or sulphur rain? Climate ‘party planners’ can’t decide thumbnail

Wild warming or sulphur rain? Climate ‘party planners’ can’t decide

Imagine you and your office mates are trying to